1. Michelin
Michelin Defender
Across the board, Michelin offers nearly a perfect blend
of grip, handling, low rolling resistance for good fuel economy, and
long tread life. In many instances, tread wear is class-leading, and
Michelin has tread wear warranties on all replacement tires, including
winter and summer tires. (Most competitors do not.) However, Michelin
tires can be pricey and that holds back a lot of potential buyers. It’s
too bad because if you factor in the outstanding tread wear, the
Michelins might be a bargain compared to other tires with a lower price.
2. Continental
Continental ExtremeWinterContact
Nipping at the heels, if not looking back at Michelin at
times, Continental consistently offers high-scoring tires. Handling and
impressive stopping grip on dry and wet roads are typical of this brand.
As a bonus, they are attractively priced.
3. Goodyear
Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric
Not every model is a hit, but in the last two years
Goodyear has come on strong with some recommended truck and ultra-high
performance tires. All-season car tires are a bit long in the tooth;
still the Goodyear Assurance TripleTread All-Season car tire is
impressive. If you need an all-season tire with great snow traction, the
Goodyear Assurance ComfortTred Touring is it.
4. Pirelli
Pirelli Scorpian Verde
Known for ultra-high performance tires, Pirelli supplies
original equipment rubber for many prestigious sports cars. Pirelli also
offers some solid models for less exotic vehicles, too. Tread life is
not always a strong point, but in recent years there have been updates
with a “Plus” added to existing models, some of which we are testing
now.